
Ranking Methodology
I love par 3 courses. My criteria for what makes a good par 3 course is much different than a regular course, and my opinions are best captured in two categories: Variety and atmosphere. I don't have as refined a formula for ranking par 3 courses since I feel like it is even more subjective than ranking regular courses, but my rankings just reflect my favorite overall experiences.
Variety: If I am at a par 3 course, I want to get to hit a variety of shots. This doesn't necessarily mean that I want to use every club in my bag, but I don't enjoy having 80 yard wedge shots repeatedly where the only option is to hit the same shot over and over again. I think one of the benefits of a par 3 course is that the greens can be much more severe than a typical course. Having interesting and different greens that may require a low hook wedge into a green, a 60 yard 7 iron drilled into a severe false front, or a high spinny wedge to hold a tiny green are the types of shots I look for. If a par 3 course doesn't offer the opportunity to hit fun shots, then I will automatically like it less.
Atmosphere: This is a tough one to objectively describe, but its kind of a you know it when you see it situation. A couple that come to mind for me that have awesome atmospheres are Schoolhouse Nine - looking at the Shenandoah mountains, having the course mostly to yourself, and watching the one maintenance worker get around to all the greens; and The Bootlegger at Forest Dunes - a feeling of remoteness despite being at a resort and feeling like the course takes you to different areas of the property despite it being all wedges while a completely random playlist plays on the speakers.
Course Rankings
Rank
Course
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
The Bootlegger (Forest Dunes)
Schoolhouse Nine
The Sandbox (Sand Valley)
Bondi Golf and Diggers Club
The Cradle (Pinehurst)
Belmont Golf Course
Cobbs Creek
Virginia Golf Center
Oak Marr Golf Center
Tussey Mountain Par 3 Course
Points
98
93
92
78
77
74
68
61
38
20
# of Holes
10
9
17
9
9
6
9
9
9
9